Skip to content
Sprue & Brush
Head to head

Craft Paint vs Miniature Paint

A craft store sells you five times the paint for a fraction of the price. The catch is real, it is specific, and it is not the one the internet shouts about.

By Brijon M.Last updated
Bottles of acrylic paint on a hobby workbench

The short answer

Use craft paint for terrain, scenery and bulk basing, where volume matters and fine detail does not. Use miniature paint on the models themselves: it is finely ground and thin-bodied so it covers in a controlled coat without filling detail. Most experienced painters own both and never argue about it.

The quick version

#ProductBest forScorePrice
1
Sixteen dropper bottles of acrylic miniature paint
Vallejo Game Color Introduction Set (72.299)Sixteen 18 ml bottles covering the whole color wheel plus three metallics. The cheapest honest route to a complete working palette.
Best cheap miniature paint set8.4Check price on Amazon
2
A dropper bottle of high-pigment acrylic miniature paint
Pro Acryl (22 ml)High-pigment acrylic in a 22 ml no-clog bottle with a glass agitator already inside. Covers in fewer coats than anything else here and dries properly matte.
Best miniature paint per milliliter9.1Check price on Amazon
3
Bottles of inexpensive acrylic craft paint
Apple Barrel Acrylic Craft Paint, 18 x 2 fl ozEighteen 2 oz bottles of matte craft acrylic for roughly what three Citadel pots cost. Wrong for a miniature's face, close to unbeatable for a hill, a ruin or forty bases.
Best for terrain and bulk basing7.5Check price on Amazon
4
Tubes of student-grade artist acrylic paint
Liquitex BASICS Acrylic, 118 ml tubesStudent-grade artist acrylic in 118 ml tubes. Far better pigment than craft paint and far cheaper per milliliter than hobby paint, but heavy-bodied and needing thinning for anything on a model.
Best middle ground8.0Check price on Amazon

Scores are our own editorial read against the criteria stated below — not a lab measurement and not a user rating. Tap a row for the full write-up.

The question behind the question

Nobody asks this because they are curious about acrylic chemistry. They ask it standing in a craft aisle holding a 2 fl oz bottle of matte acrylic, having just seen what a 12 ml pot of hobby paint costs, doing the arithmetic and wondering whether the entire miniature paint industry is a markup.

It is partly a markup and partly not, and the honest version of the answer is specific: craft paint is excellent at some of the jobs in this hobby and visibly bad at the one you care most about. Knowing which is which saves you both the money and the repaint.

Three grades of paint, not two

The usual framing is “cheap paint vs hobby paint”, which hides the useful middle. There are three things on sale:

  • Craft acrylic — Apple Barrel, FolkArt and the rest. Sold in 2 fl oz (59 ml) squeeze bottles, matte, made for wooden signs and school projects. Lower pigment load, more binder and filler, coarser grind.
  • Student artist acrylic — Liquitex BASICS and its peers, in 118 ml tubes. Real artist pigment at a student price, but heavy-bodied: formulated to hold a brush mark on canvas, not to flow off a brush onto a 28 mm model.
  • Miniature paint — Citadel, Vallejo, Army Painter, Pro Acryl. Fine grind, thin body, high pigment-to-binder ratio, in 12-22 ml containers designed to be opened a thousand times.

The third group costs the most per milliliter by a wide margin. The first costs the least by an even wider one. Where it gets interesting is that they are not ranked by quality so much as aimed at different surfaces.

What you are actually paying for

Three things, and only three.

Grind. Pigment particle size. A miniature paint is milled fine enough that a thinned coat still carries color into a recess without leaving grit on the edge. Craft paint is coarser, and on a model you see it: the paint sits in the detail rather than over it, and a thin coat looks chalky instead of translucent.

Pigment-to-binder ratio. Craft paint carries more binder and filler per unit of pigment, because it needs to cover a square foot of wood cheaply. On a miniature that means either thick coats that drown detail, or thin coats that go streaky and semi-transparent in a way you cannot control.

Delivery. Unglamorous and genuinely worth money. A dropper bottle meters out three drops; a flip-top pot opens with a thumbnail; a 22 ml Pro Acryl bottle has a glass agitator already inside it. A craft squeeze bottle gives you a blurt, and a 118 ml artist tube needs a palette and a palette knife. Over a year of painting this changes more about your experience than the pigment does.

Where craft paint genuinely wins

Not a consolation prize. For these jobs craft paint is the correct buy and hobby paint is the waste of money:

  • Terrain and scenery. A hill, a ruin, a road, a forest base. These eat paint by the fluid ounce and nobody inspects a rock for fine blending. Buy the 18-bottle craft set and stop thinking about it.
  • Bulk basing. Forty bases of brown, then a drybrush of bone. Textured, matte, forgiving, and the texture hides every weakness craft paint has. The techniques are in how to base miniatures; the paint can come from a craft store without anybody noticing. If those bases are also getting a magnet in the underside, drill them before you paint them rather than after.
  • Big flat vehicle panels — with care. A tank hull is closer to a terrain piece than to a face. Thinned properly and sealed, craft paint survives here.
  • Learning to control a brush. If you are painting your first ten test models to find out whether you enjoy this, cheap paint on cheap plastic is a rational experiment.
  • Mixing texture paste and basing mud. Craft paint plus sand, plus PVA, plus a little filler, makes exactly what a branded texture paint makes. See the basing materials picks for the rest of that recipe.

Where it visibly fails

Equally specific, and these are the reasons the hobby ranges exist.

Faces and fine detail. The failure here is not subtle. Coarse pigment and heavy binder fill the eye sockets, soften the nose, and turn a crisp detail into a lump. No amount of technique fixes a paint that is physically too thick for the gap it is sitting in.

Layering and blending. Both depend on applying a slightly different color in a controlled, semi-transparent coat. Craft paint thinned to that transparency goes chalky, because what is left when you dilute the binder is filler. You can blend with it; you will fight it the entire way.

Washes. A hobby wash is a specific formulation — pigment, a flow agent and a matte medium that lets it pool in recesses and not stain raised surfaces. Craft paint plus water is not that; it dries in tide marks. This is the single clearest case for buying the dedicated product, and the washes roundup explains why.

Durability on a handled model. Craft paint is formulated for a decorative object on a shelf. A gaming model is picked up every week and dropped in a foam tray. It chips. That is survivable if you varnish — see how to seal miniatures — and unsurvivable if you do not.

Following a recipe. Nearly every painting tutorial you will ever read names a Citadel color. A craft paint called “Cloudy Day” maps to nothing, so every tutorial becomes a translation exercise. This is a real cost for a beginner and almost none for an experienced painter; a conversion chart only helps between hobby ranges.

The middle option almost nobody considers

Student artist acrylic is the interesting answer and it gets ignored because it lives in a different shop. A 118 ml tube of Liquitex BASICS titanium white or mars black has real pigment in it, costs a fraction per milliliter of what a hobby pot does, and will outlast several armies.

Its problem is body, not quality. Straight from the tube it is heavy — built to hold a brush mark — so everything you do with it on a model starts by thinning it on a palette. That is a skill rather than a step, and how to thin miniature paint is the prerequisite. With a wet palette under it, thinned artist acrylic behaves very well.

Where it earns its place: white, black, and any color you use in volume. Mixing custom colors stops feeling expensive when the white costs a tenth of what a hobby white does, and that changes how you paint more than any single hobby purchase.

Side by side

 Craft acrylicStudent artist acrylicMiniature paint
Typical container59 ml squeeze bottle118 ml tube12-22 ml pot or dropper
Cost per mlLowest by a wide marginLowHighest
GrindCoarseFineFinest
Body from the containerMedium, variableHeavyThin, ready to use
Fine detailPoorFair once thinnedDesigned for it
Terrain and basingExcellentExcellentWasteful
Matches tutorialsNoNoYes (Citadel especially)
Washes and contrast paintsNot available — buy the hobby productYes

The split most painters actually land on

Nobody who paints seriously uses one or the other exclusively. The stable arrangement, and the one worth copying:

  • Miniature paint for everything on the model — basecoats, layers, faces, metallics, washes, contrast paints.
  • Craft or artist acrylic for everything around the model — bases in bulk, terrain, scenery, texture mixes, and the white and black you burn through mixing.
  • A hobby set as the spine of the palette. A 16-bottle Vallejo Game Color set or a Citadel starter box gives you the colors tutorials name and the formulation that works on a face; the cheap paint fills in volume around it.

If you are at the very start of this and have not bought anything yet, the beginner paint sets is the page to read next, and how many paints to start with will stop you buying forty.

What this saves, realistically

Worth being straight about, because the savings are real and smaller than the aisle makes them look. We do not print prices on this site — a stale number is worse than none, and the buy links go to live listings — but the shape is clear enough.

Craft bottles hold roughly five times what a 12 ml hobby pot does and sell for a small fraction of the price, so on a pure cost-per-milliliter basis it is not close. On terrain and bulk basing, where you genuinely use that volume, the saving is substantial and obvious.

On the models themselves, the saving mostly evaporates. A miniature uses a startlingly small amount of paint: a 12 ml pot of a main color will basecoat an entire squad, and nobody runs out of the colors they paint models with — they run out of the colors they paint bases and hills with. Buying craft paint to save money on the model itself is optimizing the part of the budget that was never the problem, and paying for it in results. The genuinely large costs of starting are the models and brushes, which is what the cost of starting Warhammer works through in full.

The verdict

Buy miniature paint for the miniature. The grind and the body are the product, and they are the two things that decide whether a face looks painted or filled in. A cheap hobby set beats craft paint on a model every time.

Buy craft paint for terrain, scenery and bulk basing. Not as a compromise — as the right tool. Hobby paint on a hillside is money set on fire.

Buy a tube of student artist white and black whatever else you do. It is the cheapest change to how freely you mix colors that the hobby offers.

Do not try to substitute washes. Craft paint plus water is not a wash and there is no home recipe that reliably behaves like one. This is the single purchase where the hobby product is simply a different thing.

If what you actually wanted was the cheapest honest route to a full working palette rather than the cheapest paint, miniature paint brands compared ranks the hobby ranges on exactly that, and Army Painter vs Citadel is the head-to-head most beginners are really choosing between.

The picks in full

#1 · Best cheap miniature paint setVallejo

Vallejo Game Color Introduction Set (72.299)

Sixteen 18 ml bottles covering the whole color wheel plus three metallics. The cheapest honest route to a complete working palette.

Paints16 × 18 ml
Bottle typeDropper
Metallics3 (silver, gun metal, gold)
RangeGame Color

What it gets right

  • 288 ml of paint in one box — roughly double a Citadel starter set for comparable money
  • Includes the three metallics most sets leave out, so you are not buying silver separately
  • Spans the full color wheel rather than one faction's scheme, so it fits any army

Who it is wrong for

  • No brush, no primer, no shade — it is paint and nothing else
  • Some colors need two thin coats where a Citadel Base needs one
  • Vallejo names match no tutorial you will watch; keep a conversion chart open

Scored against this page’s criteria

Beginner-proof6.5
Color coverage9.0
Cost per ml10.0
Tutorial match5.0

Specs from the manufacturer: Vallejo product page

Sixteen dropper bottles of acrylic miniature paint
Our score8.4/10
Check price on Amazon

We do not publish prices. Amazon shows the current one, which is the only one that is ever right. #ad · how this is funded

#2 · Best miniature paint per milliliterMonument Hobbies

Pro Acryl (22 ml)

High-pigment acrylic in a 22 ml no-clog bottle with a glass agitator already inside. Covers in fewer coats than anything else here and dries properly matte.

Volume22 ml
BottleNo-clog cap, dropper behavior with a twist top
AgitatorGlass bead included
FinishMatte

What it gets right

  • Pigment density is the highest here — yellow and red cover in two coats instead of four
  • 22 ml per bottle against Citadel's 12 ml, at a similar shelf price
  • The no-clog cap genuinely does not weld shut, which is the Citadel pot's defining failure

Who it is wrong for

  • The range is built around a painter's palette, not a game's official color names, so tutorials need translating
  • Shelf availability is thinner than Citadel, Vallejo or Army Painter in most countries
  • No contrast-style one-coat line of its own, so a speed-painting workflow needs a second brand

Scored against this page’s criteria

Coverage10.0
Range breadth7.5
Bottle design9.5
Value per ml9.0

Specs from the manufacturer: Monument Hobbies product page

A dropper bottle of high-pigment acrylic miniature paint
Our score9.1/10
Check price on Amazon

We do not publish prices. Amazon shows the current one, which is the only one that is ever right. #ad · how this is funded

#3 · Best for terrain and bulk basingApple Barrel

Apple Barrel Acrylic Craft Paint, 18 x 2 fl oz

Eighteen 2 oz bottles of matte craft acrylic for roughly what three Citadel pots cost. Wrong for a miniature's face, close to unbeatable for a hill, a ruin or forty bases.

Set18 bottles x 2 fl oz (59 ml)
FinishMatte
Made inUSA (Plaid Enterprises)
Volume per bottleAbout 5x a 12 ml hobby pot
PigmentCraft grade — coarser than a miniature range

What it gets right

  • Volume is the whole argument: terrain and basing eat paint, and this is the cheapest honest way to feed them
  • Matte out of the bottle, which is what a rock or a road wants anyway
  • Sold in every craft store, so running out mid-project is a same-day fix

Who it is wrong for

  • Coarser pigment and more binder than a miniature paint — it clogs fine detail and dries with visible texture on a face
  • Colors are named for crafts, not armies, so matching a published recipe is guesswork
  • Consistency varies bottle to bottle; some arrive runny, some nearly dry

Scored against this page’s criteria

Cost per ml10.0
Fine detail3.0
Coverage per coat5.5
Matches painted recipes2.0

Specs from the manufacturer: Apple Barrel product page

Bottles of inexpensive acrylic craft paint
Our score7.5/10
Check price on Amazon

We do not publish prices. Amazon shows the current one, which is the only one that is ever right. #ad · how this is funded

#4 · Best middle groundLiquitex

Liquitex BASICS Acrylic, 118 ml tubes

Student-grade artist acrylic in 118 ml tubes. Far better pigment than craft paint and far cheaper per milliliter than hobby paint, but heavy-bodied and needing thinning for anything on a model.

Size118 ml (4 oz) tubes; sets of 6, 7 and 12
GradeStudent artist acrylic
BodyHeavy — made for a palette knife and a canvas
FinishSatin to matte depending on color
Volume per tubeAbout 10x a 12 ml hobby pot

What it gets right

  • Real artist pigment load, so mixes stay clean instead of going chalky the way craft paint does
  • A tube of titanium white or mars black at this price changes how freely you mix custom colors
  • Excellent for terrain, large vehicles and basing texture, where volume and tinting strength both matter

Who it is wrong for

  • Heavy body straight from the tube — on a miniature it has to be thinned, and that is a skill, not a step
  • No dropper and no flip-top: a tube is awkward at a painting desk and dries out if the cap is left off
  • No miniature-specific colors, no washes, no contrast paints — it solves one third of the palette

Scored against this page’s criteria

Cost per ml8.5
Fine detail6.0
Coverage per coat8.0
Matches painted recipes3.0

Specs from the manufacturer: Liquitex product page

Tubes of student-grade artist acrylic paint
Our score8.0/10
Check price on Amazon

We do not publish prices. Amazon shows the current one, which is the only one that is ever right. #ad · how this is funded

FAQ

Questions people actually ask

Can I paint Warhammer with craft paint?
You can, and the models will look it. Craft acrylic is coarser and carries more binder, so it fills fine detail and goes chalky when thinned enough to layer with. Use it for terrain, scenery and bulk basing, where it is genuinely the better buy, and put miniature paint on the models themselves.
What is the difference between craft paint and miniature paint?
Grind, pigment-to-binder ratio and delivery. Miniature paint is milled finer and carries more pigment per unit of binder, so a thin coat covers without drowning detail. Craft paint is formulated to cover a square foot of wood cheaply, which is the opposite problem. The container matters too: a dropper or flip-top pot versus a squeeze bottle.
Is Apple Barrel paint good for miniatures?
It is good for the terrain and bases around miniatures and poor on the miniatures themselves. The 2 fl oz bottles hold about five times a 12 ml hobby pot, which is exactly what bulk basing and scenery need. On a face or fine armor detail the coarser pigment is visible.
Can I use Liquitex BASICS on miniatures?
Yes, once you thin it. Student artist acrylic has real pigment load and far better mixing behavior than craft paint, but it is heavy-bodied because it was made for canvas. Thinned on a wet palette it works well, and a tube of white or black is dramatically cheaper per milliliter than the hobby equivalent.
Do I need special paint for miniatures?
For the model, effectively yes — the fine grind and thin body are what the product is. For everything else in the hobby, no. Terrain, scenery, basing texture and the white and black you use in volume are all better served by craft or artist acrylic, which is why most experienced painters own both.
Can I make my own wash from craft paint?
Not reliably. A hobby wash is pigment plus a flow agent plus a matte medium, tuned to pool in recesses without staining raised surfaces. Craft paint thinned with water dries in tide marks instead. Washes are the one category where the dedicated hobby product has no honest substitute.
Does craft paint need to be sealed on miniatures?
Yes, if the model gets handled. Craft acrylic is formulated for a decorative object that sits still, and it chips on a gaming model that is picked up every week and stored in foam. A matte varnish fixes it, and skipping varnish is how people conclude craft paint 'does not work' when the real problem was the lack of a topcoat.

More in Miniature Paints and Paint Sets, or start from the beginning with what to buy first.

Sources

Read next